Nihilism:
State of Freedom, or Mindset of Ruin?
By VJ
From: Texas, US
Does anything we do really matter? If humanity truly is rinsing and repeating every day, and everyone is just as miserable as anyone else, what can you possibly do that would matter in the long run?
Nihilism, a philosophical view of the world stating that existence in its whole holds no meaning or intrinsic value. An idea that has become much more prominent in recent history as ideologies have shifted. The history of nihilism can be broken down into equally important categories that help define the topic. An example of this is political nihilism.
Political nihilism is known as the of characterization of political attitude. Used to discredit extreme political ideologies and anti-establishment movements, it's been used for centuries to discredit other political parties. In Russia, this became big in the 19th centuries. Socialist and anarchists' movements gained popularity. Often, critics called them nihilist to dismiss them and use it as slander to protect the status quo.
One critic was Russian writer Fyodor Dostoyevsky, apprehended for being part of a socialist group, he was sentenced to death by the Russian Zar. However, right before his execution, he was instead sentenced to spend years in a labor camp. After the years of punishment he went through, he spent the rest of his years rejecting socialism and other revolutionary causes. He felt they ignored the dignity of humanity and our need for individuality. He strongly felt that socialism would deny humans the right to feel the fruits of their work.
Modern populism is political nihilism or can otherwise be characterized as such. Both left and right variations agree that the system needs to be overhaled, and have latched onto the myth and, unfortunately, the reality that our political reps have become too corrupt to salvage. A more modern example of this is what Trump has done, grabing onto this belief to become president twice. Many nihilists (except for anarchists) will likely not openly identify as such. Friedrich Nietzche, existentialist and philosopher, is often associated with nihilism and widely thought to embrace it, but it true that he advocated for a belief in nothingness? Friedrich Nietzche was not an advocate for nihilism, though it does play an important role in his writing.
Political nihilism says that nothing matters, that the systems we live under are indifferent to our existence. But the system is actually much worse than that. It's not indifferent, nor does it ignore you. Instead, it actively seeks to know everything about you and uses such information to control and suppress you. Your name, income, family, even your struggles; data brokers collect these fragments and package them into long lists that are sold to the highest bidder.
Cultural nihilism is a belief system and social phenomenon in which people reject traditional cultural values, moral frameworks, and institutional norms, often leading to a sense of purposelessness, cynicism, or the urge to tear down established systems. With the rise of scientific explanations of the universe and life on earth, the dominant belief in the Christan God was rapidly weakening in Nietzsche's time.
Philosophers in the mid 19th century were trying to rationally justify the Christan values that were quickly losing their spiritual underpinning. Ultimately, Nietzche believed this was a lost cause, and that humanity risked sinking into a cultural abyss. He suggested that they stem from the resentment of slaves towards their masters. Throughout religion, the slaves elevated the opposite values of their masters, which supported their own way of being. They were meek, humble, and condemning. They condemned the value of their masters, suggesting a life lived this way would land them an eternity in hell. For a religion where forgiveness is so important, it's odd that eternal damnation is always such a staple. Nietzche suggests that this contradiction comes from the nature of resentment.
Chrisan nihilism, Nietzche takes this a bit father, and says that Christianity along with the beliefs of Plato and Socrates was nihilistic. They had placed all values in a realm beyond their own, a realm of their god and the heavens. As someone who is raised in a Christan family, you can see that this life that you live now is only leading to your eternity, not the main event. This is why Nietzche claims this is a form of nihilism.
Plato and Socrates devalued the real world by putting ideas above how we experience life. They used reason as a tool to judge life from an external point of view. In Plato's allegory of the cave, he suggests that our sensory experience is like being trapped in a cave looking at the shadows on the wall. These shadows for Plato are illusions. The real world, which for him was the world of ideas, exists outside of the cave.
Plato and Socrates ultimately suggest that the world you experience is an error compared to the perfect world of ideas that can only be discovered through reason. For Nietzche, this is a big problem as it devalues the physical world and makes it impossible to create values based on life. Plato and Socrates would accuse those worldly values of just being shadows. Nichze himself was not a nihilist. He believed that nihilism was harmful to humanity, leaving people in a state of despair and directionlessness and prone to destructive tendencies. He wanted to help humanity overcome nihilism and move towards something better.
To accomplish this, he identified two ways of responding to it. Passively and actively. The passive person finds no value in anything and despairs at the lack of a greater purpose in a life that they feel that they've lost. They turn their back on existence and treat it as a punishment. This was how Nze described Buddhism, Hinduism, and Arthur Scopenhower's philosophy. He rejected the idea that life is suffering or that being reborn is a punishment. His response was to say yes to the world to embrace it as it is beyond the structures we impose on it such as religion, science, and even philosophy.
To actively respond to nihilism, we must re-evaluate our lives and consistently and continually create new ones. It's a constant process of deconstruction and creation. If we don't continuously overcome values and norms, we risk nihilism again as these values will eventually not reflect the lives we live. For Nietzche, these values needed to be aesthetic ones about life and vitality. In other words, he wanted them to be affirmed. Logic and reason are too systematic.
Like Christianity, they place a superior dimension above our physical existence. Nietzche is often considered a moral nihilist, but that's not completely true. As we will see, a moral nihilist believes that there are no absolute moral or ethical values. When we talk about morality, we are just referring to social constructs likely derived from emotions and power relations. Nietzche didn't believe in the absolute nature of moral values. The universal morals that philosophers have formulated are better understood not as exercises or reason but as coming from that person's physiological or psychic state.
As Nietzche explains, every great philosophy so far has been the personal confessions of its author and a kind of involuntary and unconscious memoir. When we read the moral works of philosophers Emanuel Kant or John Stewart Mills, we learn not about universal ethical systems but about who we are. Just as Nietzche believed that we should always be constructing new values, we should also be working on moral values.
However, the idea is not to create values for everyone equally. People are different and should embrace morals that are more suited to them. Nietzche believed in higher and lower types, for example, insisting that each should have their own moral value set. Free will was always an issue for him. Moral systems presume that people have free will and are able to choose between good and evil. But Nietzche along with many modern scientists doesn't believe that humans possess free will and are therefore not morally responsible for their own choices.
For the average person, this take on morality will come across as nihilism. We are very used to thinking about this in terms of moral absolutes. Our culture is still very informed by the long shadow of western philosophy and religion. But for Nichze, the idea is to push beyond nihilism into a mode of value creation. The philosopher was certainly bold for his time, but he wasn't the first thinker to question moral ideals. Some of the earliest critiques of universal morals can be found over 2,000 years ago in a Chinese religion.
Daoism is unique among religions in that it is uninterested in moral claims or in any notion of a greater purpose that would inform our actions. For the creators of Daoism, morality is an ineffective way to deal with our problems. It's not particularly good, for example, at encouraging others to behave better, as righteousness often inspires the opposite, and it only temporarily seems to soothe us like painkillers. Daoism instead suggests that morality comes from finding an outcome desirable and wanting to repeat that outcome despite how futile that struggle will be. When we try to eliminate what we consider morally bad, we try to control what we cannot control. It's like demanding more flowers and less dirt where one requires the other.
For the Dao, moral ideals result in hypocrisy and an attitude of hostility to parts of ourselves that don't live up to our moral standards. We often then project that hostility outward to target others who don't live up to our moral expectations. That's why you often see morally righteous people targeting others while ultimately being hypocrites themselves.
According to Daoism, the source of our problems is that we are not following the great Dao or the way. You can follow this path through a series of practices such as taking non-deliberate action leading to a sort of harmony. You accept the bounds of flour and dirt and you don't demand more of one than the other. Many would go on to describe Daoism as a form of moral nihilism. But just like with Nietze, that misses the point. The religion rejects the notion of living with a greater purpose. It's more about following a way than a purpose, and that is what creates harmony. Beliefs are ultimately useless to the Dao. However, this lack of a greater purpose or meaning is a difficult pill for many to swallow, especially those with a background steeped in modern religous and western norms.
After Nze described the death of God, many philosophers reckoned with the challenge of meaning. This created a philosophical movement known as the atheist existentialism. Life has no meaning. There is no existential human nature and no grand purpose. Existentialist writers in the 20th century wrestled with these conclusions that the death of God had laid bare. Without the illusions that society was built upon, we're left with nothingness. We're in a state of nihilism. Just like Nichze, philosophers of this movement tried to respond actively to nothingness.
The French existentialist Jean Paul Sart insists that because of our nihilist reality, we are condemned to be free. We are thrown into this world with no default essence or purpose. And as a result, we are ultimately responsible for everything we do. He goes on further to suggest that we are free at every moment. Even when tied down with ropes, we are free to choose how we approach that situation. When we stand on a bridge high above a body of water, some of us are struck with a fear not that we will accidentally fall, but that we'll throw ourselves off. Sart described this feeling as an anguish towards our freedom. Nothing prevents us from throwing ourselves off. We are always free to do so. To live authentically, we have to take full responsibility for our freedom by choosing our own values and how we live in general. We can't appeal to a higher purpose and a pre-existing set of rules. We must choose for ourselves.
For Sart, nihilism is the burden of freedom. The French writer Alber Camu took a different approach to the concept of nothingness. He found the idea of pursuing our own meaning or creating values to be self-defeating. There's no escaping the absurdity of human life. We yearn for meaning from a world that doesn't give us answers. He compared human absurdity to Seisphus's struggle.
In a in a Greek myth, Seisphus was forced to push a boulder up a hill for an eternity. When he reached the top, the boulder fell right back down, and he had to start again. For Kimu, this struggle is just like our continual push for meaning. Just when we think we found a sense of purpose, it eludes us. Life has no concrete answers for us, and the boulder rolls back down the hill. Kimu's answer to the problem of nothingness was to live facing absurdity directly. We should confront nihilism by carrying on despite its consequences. To live authentically is to be fully conscious of the abyss and to defy it with our head held high, just like Seisphus boldly marching down the mountain.
While atheist existentialists grappled meaning in a world that offered none, post-modernist philosophers rejected any sort of meta narrative. They would not entertain them or seek them out in some vain struggle. Instead, they embraced nihilism in an almost cheerful way. They were extremely skeptical of truth claims and moral hierarchies. And with this attitude, they deconstructed how truth functions in society. The French philosopher Jean Franis Leotard described these meta narratives as language games that we use to make sense of the world. These are fields like religion, science, and philosophy. There's no all-encompassing order for the world that we can understand. and we just have these language games to interpret them. Leotard believes that these games shouldn't compete for supremacy in the way science sometimes is used to undermine religion. He insisted that they should exist in parallel running alongside one another with no hierarchy.
Another French philosopher Michelle Fuko described this process as a form of enlightenment. We are freeing ourselves from the assumptions about knowledge that controls our lives. In his view, knowledge is not objective or neutral. It's shaped by power relations. Power influences how knowledge is produced and even what is considered to be knowledge.
When producing research or journalism, for example, we don't just freely follow our interests or act randomly. Power determines what is an acceptable pursuit and what isn't. Often what is considered knowledge is determined by its economic value. Does it make the institution you're operating in more revenue? Does it free up space in the budget? Does it draw an audience via institutions? Power uses knowledge to shape individuals. And as Fuko insists, this is to create compliant citizens. This is why most institutions in society are designed like prisons. The idea is that subjects in these places such as schools or psychiatric wards are either being observed or in a state where they are potentially always watched. The individual then conforms to their behavior under the assumption that they are being monitored and could be punished even if they aren't necessarily always under that watchful eye. What all postmodernism has in common is a near full embrace of nihilism which aims to disassemble the larger narratives that control our lives. It is an active deconstruction inspired by the likes of Nze.
Only they weren't so interested in creating new values. The point is to free us from the imperfect knowledge that insidiously controls our behavior in society and the many institutions that it comprises. I've seen people online embrace something called optimistic nihilism and I wanted to clarify what that is in the context of the categories that we've already discussed. The basic idea is that life is meaningless, but that means that we're free to find joy and meaning wherever we please. Some of you may have already realized that optimistic nihilism sounds awfully similar to existentialism, and it is, except that the concept is much simpler and perhaps created by people who were only so familiar with the history of existentialism and philosophy in general.
In our exploration of nihilism, there's a common thread in each classification. The philosophers and writers involved don't consider themselves nihilists. Given our close examination, we've demonstrated that they're not advocating for nothingness, but deal with it directly in their writing. They bravely face the reality of nihilism and actively negotiate what to do despite its consequences. But there is a notion of a true nihilism. One who sits in nothingness and passively lets it consume them. This is what we call a post-modern nihilist.
Well, not to be confused with the postmodernists that we just discussed, although postmodernism is often referred to as postmodern nihilism. I'm sorry if this is getting confusing. They're described as being indifferent conformists who put all of their energy and effort into hedonistic endeavors. They're deeply resentful and alienated, occasionally exploding into violence. They have no sense of greater purpose and languish in their absence. The philosophers who reckon with nihilism are generally trying to steer humanity away from becoming this kind of person.
Nichi described a similar type as quotes the last man. People who preoccupy themselves with comfort and security while taking no risks. You could also describe them as passive nihilists. In Kimu's book, The Stranger, his main character, Mero, finds no value in anything. He's indifferent to his mother's passing and feels nothing in his relationships. Maro is also not emotionally impacted when he kills someone. In the book, however, he eventually embraces the absurdity of life as he's about to be executed. What is clear from every type of nihilism is that those who engage with it were not interested in sitting idly in nothingness. The point was always about navigating the world without a pre-existing purpose and universal truths.
Finding no value in anything is not a healthy way to be. As NZ famously said, "He who fights with monsters might take care lest he thereby become a monster. And if you gaze for long into an abyss, the abyss also gazes into you. When you spend so much time dwelling on nothingness, you slowly become it. Finding value is important for your well-being. It may not be a universal truth, but most of us will struggle as we sit in that abyss.
The lack of a greater truth was not the most interesting part about nihilism. It is the opportunity to pursue new or just different truths separate from the narratives that have shaped society around us. The established truths we're accustomed to can be comforting for sure, but they can also alienate others and lead to dangerous convictions. People kill for moral convictions all the time. And you could argue that large-scale murder is often done for the sake of a diluted sense of morality. But what if we're free to assign purpose to whatever we'd like? Sometimes we belittle our interests because they don't contribute to a higher purpose that was instilled in us at a young age. We may reject the idea of wandering aimlessly up a mountain because it doesn't improve our workplace skills. We may reject friendships because our faith in God devalues the other person and their lifestyle. As consumerists, we often indulge in the immediate pleasures of media consumption or video games because they reflect an ingrained value that we have. You work hard and you play hard. Your consumption contributes to economic growth and so it has value. Coming face to face with nihilism is a painful process that does open new possibilities in our lives. But it's not all misery. It can also relieve pressure and anxiety from the demands of those higher purposes. Most of us don't live up to the standards that are placed on us and now we don't need to worry about it.
What a terrifying, beautiful mentality.
​
SOURCES
​
Brangham, W., & Clune Hartman, S. (2023, February 19). Personal user data from mental health apps being sold, report finds. PBS News. https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/personal-user-data-from-mental-health-apps-being-sold-report-finds
Kim, J. (2023, February). Data brokers and the sale of americans’ mental health data. Tech Policy @ Sanford. https://techpolicy.sanford.duke.edu/data-brokers-and-the-sale-of-americans-mental-health-data/
Wicks, R. (2017). Nietzsche’s life and works (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy). Stanford.Edu. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/nietzsche-life-works/